Grades: Understanding, not Obedience
The New York Times got me thinking, in its November 28, 2010 article " No More A's for Good Behavior ." The Potsdam, NY Public Schools, led by Superintendent Patrick Brady, are right on. As I concluded in a previous blog post, " Extra Credit: The Downfall of America ?", grades must be a reflection of knowledge learned, information synthesized, skills demonstrated, not a reflection of behavior. I have opened up the following conversation individually with teachers, but have not yet taken it on with the staff of the whole school in which I work - yet. Grades must not be a reflection of behavior, but of understanding. This includes the a big piece of student responsibility: homework. The excuse that "if students do not homework and are not penalized for not completing it, then won't ever learn to do it!" is simply hogwash. We should be creating homework assignments that are essential, and if it uncomfortably illuminates our own homework polici...